I Was Too Late to the Fad: What I Learned from Chasing Pop-It Toys

Let me tell you about the time I learned the difference between a trend and a fad—the hard way. This isn't just a cautionary tale; it's a £3,200 lesson that completely changed how I evaluate opportunities.

The Hype: When Everyone Was Talking About It

It was spring 2021, and Pop-It fidget toys were everywhere. My social media feeds were flooded with videos of people popping the satisfying silicone bubbles. Friends were texting me, "Are you selling these yet?" Even my 8-year-old niece was asking for one.

The numbers looked incredible:

• TikTok videos with #popit: 2.8 billion views
• Amazon search volume: up 1,200% in 30 days
• Google Trends: "pop it toy" at all-time high
• Social media mentions: 50,000+ per day

I was seeing Pop-Its in every store, every playground, every kid's backpack. The FOMO was real.

![Image placeholder: Social media screenshots of Pop-It videos]

The Red Flags I Ignored

Looking back, the warning signs were everywhere—I just chose to ignore them:

Red Flag #1: The Saturation Point

When I finally checked Amazon, I found over 2,000 sellers already listing Pop-It toys. The top 100 results were nearly identical products with similar photos, descriptions, and pricing. This should have been my first clue.

Red Flag #2: The Price War

Prices were in freefall:

• Week 1: $12-15 per unit
• Week 2: $8-10 per unit
• Week 3: $5-7 per unit
• Week 4: $3-5 per unit

When prices drop this fast, it usually means the market is oversaturated and demand is waning.

Red Flag #3: The Review Velocity Crash

While total reviews were still climbing, the rate of new reviews was dropping:

• Early adopters: 50+ reviews per day
• Peak: 200+ reviews per day
• When I entered: 20-30 reviews per day
• Two weeks later: 5-10 reviews per day

Red Flag #4: The Social Media Plateau

The social media buzz had plateaued. While total views were still high, new content creation was slowing down. The "trending" phase was over.

The Fatal Decision: Jumping In Anyway

Despite all these red flags, I convinced myself I could still profit. My reasoning:

• "There's still demand, just more competition"
• "I can compete on quality and customer service"
• "Even if I break even, it's good experience"
• "My supplier has a unique design that will stand out"

So I placed an order for 500 units at $4.50 each—a $2,250 investment.

The Reality Check: What Actually Happened

Week 1: The Optimism

• Listed 50 units to test the waters
• Priced at $8.99 (above market average)
• Got 3 sales in the first week
• Thought: "Not bad, let's scale up"

Week 2: The Competition

• Listed the remaining 450 units
• Competitors had dropped prices to $3.99
• I was getting buried in search results
• Sales dropped to 1-2 per day

Week 3: The Panic

• Sales completely dried up
• Competitors were now at $2.99
• My listings were on page 8+ of search results
• Started running PPC ads at $1.50 per click

Week 4: The Desperation

• Dropped price to $2.99 (losing money on each sale)
• Increased PPC budget to $50/day
• Still only getting 1-2 sales per day
• Started offering bundle deals

The Final Numbers

• Total investment: $2,250
• Total revenue: $1,180
• Net loss: $1,070
• Units sold: 180 out of 500 (36%)
• Average selling price: $6.55
• PPC spend: $800
• Final inventory: 320 units (now worthless)

The Aftermath: Lessons Learned

This failure taught me more than any success ever could:

1. The Difference Between Trends and Fads

Trends (like the hoodie story):

• Solve real problems
• Have staying power
• Grow steadily over time
• Create lasting market demand

Fads (like Pop-Its):

• Are novelty-driven
• Spike and crash quickly
• Have no real utility
• Create temporary demand

2. The Saturation Test

Now I always ask:

• How many sellers are already in this space?
• Are prices stable or dropping?
• Is the market still growing or plateauing?
• Can I differentiate meaningfully?

If there are more than 100 similar listings and prices are dropping, I pass.

3. The Timing Trap

The best time to enter a market is:

• Early: When there's demand but limited supply
• Never: When there's demand but oversupply

The worst time is when everyone else is already there.

4. The Data Doesn't Lie

I should have looked at:

• Review velocity trends (not just total reviews)
• Price stability (not just current prices)
• Search volume growth (not just current volume)
• Competitor analysis (not just product research)

The Framework: How to Avoid Fad Traps

Here's my 5-step process for evaluating opportunities:

Step 1: The Saturation Check

• Count similar listings on Amazon
• Check if top 20 results are nearly identical
• Look for price wars in progress
• Red flag: 100+ similar listings with dropping prices

Step 2: The Timing Analysis

• Check when the trend started
• Look at search volume growth rate
• Analyze review velocity trends
• Red flag: Search volume plateauing, review velocity dropping

Step 3: The Differentiation Test

• Can I offer something genuinely different?
• Do I have a unique value proposition?
• Can I compete on more than just price?
• Red flag: No meaningful way to differentiate

Step 4: The Exit Strategy

• What's my break-even point?
• How quickly can I liquidate if needed?
• What's my maximum acceptable loss?
• Red flag: No clear exit strategy

Step 5: The Gut Check

• Am I excited about this product?
• Do I understand the target customer?
• Can I add real value to the market?
• Red flag: Just chasing money, not passion

The Silver Lining: What I Gained

This failure wasn't a total loss. It taught me:

• Better risk management: Never invest more than I can afford to lose
• Smarter market analysis: Look beyond surface-level metrics
• Faster decision making: Sometimes the best decision is to pass
• Improved discipline: Stick to my criteria, even when FOMO is strong

The Pop-It Aftermath: What Happened Next

Those 320 leftover Pop-Its? I donated them to local schools and children's hospitals. The kids loved them, and it felt better than throwing them away.

The experience also led me to develop my current trend-spotting framework, which has helped me avoid similar mistakes and catch real trends early.

Your Turn: How to Spot Fads vs. Trends

Here's what to look for:

Signs of a Fad:

• Sudden, explosive growth
• Lots of identical products
• Price wars and dropping margins
• Social media buzz without substance
• No real problem being solved

Signs of a Real Trend:

• Steady, consistent growth
• Room for differentiation
• Stable or rising prices
• Solves a real problem
• Has staying power

The Bottom Line

Sometimes the best move is to pass. Not every opportunity is worth pursuing, and not every "trend" is actually a trend.

The Pop-It disaster cost me 3,200, but it saved me from much bigger mistakes down the road. Now I'd rather miss a fad than get stuck with dead inventory again.

Remember: When everyone's talking about it, you're probably too late. The best opportunities are the ones nobody's talking about yet.

---

Want to learn more about avoiding fad traps? Join our community forum where we share real-time market analysis and help each other spot the difference between trends and fads.